Carbon News
  • Members
    • Login
      Forgot Password?
    • Not a member? Subscribe
    • Forgot Password
      Back to Login
    • Not a member? Subscribe
  • Home
  • New Zealand
    • Politics
    • Energy
    • Agriculture
    • Carbon emissions
    • Transport
    • Forestry
    • Business
  • Markets
    • Analysis
    • NZ carbon price
  • International
    • Australia
    • United States
    • China
    • Europe
    • United Kingdom
    • Canada
    • Asia
    • Pacific
    • Antarctic/Arctic
    • Africa
    • South America
    • United Nations
  • News Direct
    • Media releases
    • Climate calendar
  • About Carbon News
    • Contact us
    • Advertising
    • Subscribe
    • Service
    • Policies

Beef + Lamb New Zealand respond to meat lobby financing academic research claims

16 Feb 2023


Beef + Lamb New Zealand respond to a Carbon News story about its support for a tour of New Zealand by US academic Dr Frank Mitloehner who the New York Times has reported receives millions of dollars in funding from the meat industry in the United States.

Dear Editor, 

 

We were pleased to see Carbon News highlighting the visit by Dr Frank Mitloehner that Beef + Lamb New Zealand is supporting, however there were a number of inaccuracies that we felt was important to set the record straight on.


Dr Mitloehner is visiting New Zealand to speak on improving sustainability in animal agriculture – including reducing greenhouse gas emissions from the livestock sector – and diving into California’s approach where the state has ambitious methane reduction targets and is making good progress towards meeting goals.

 

Dr Mitloehner is working with farmers on reducing their emissions and encouraging them to use new technologies where they are available. The trust he has built among producers and the agriculture sector allows him to have productive conversations that will lead to real reductions. Some technologies are already available in California, given their different farming systems, and farmers are making good progress using them. 

 

A recent report from the CLEAR Center he co-authored emphasised that California dairy farmers will need to continue to reduce their methane emissions to reach the State’s goals and there are opportunities to do that: New Report: California is Pioneering a Pathway to Significant Dairy Methane Reduction | CLEAR Center (ucdavis.edu)

 

 Here is a link to an earlier report by the State of California in 2021 on progress on reducing their agriculture emissions: Assessing California’s Climate Policies—Agriculture.  We understand since this report was released, further research has indicated the programmes in place in California have been more successful than expected.  

 

CLEAR and Dr Mitloehner have a high output of useful research on agricultural GHG mitigation and Dr Mitloehner leads work investigating ways to reduce emissions. 

 

Part of Dr Mitloehner’s work is also building understanding of methane’s impact on the climate.

 

We were disappointed that Dr Mitloehner’s lecture on the science behind methane’s impact on warming was portrayed in your article as being contradictory to the scientific consensus. This assertion is incorrect. The IPCC (pg 927/8 Chapter 7) recognises that the short lived nature of methane means that its emissions do not need to reach zero.  

 

This is also the scientific basis for New Zealand having a split gas target for methane in the Zero Carbon Act. 

 

The GWP* metric is acknowledged by the IPCC as more accurately quantifying the warming effect of short-lived gases. It isn't a plot to give livestock agriculture a free ride. The underlying issue is the accurate measure of methane's warming. 

 

You can calculate this using the equations of atmospheric physics - or much more simply, by using an accurate metric.

 

The opposition to GWP* - largely from Europe - comes not from contesting the science, but from (incorrect) assumptions about how it would be used in policy. That is where the 'free ride for farmers' claim comes from.

 

Tackling agricultural emissions is an important issue and we see agriculture as a potential solution to climate change in its ability to both reduce emissions and sequester carbon through farming practices and incorporating forestry into our systems.

 

Working with international partners on these issues is a key part of our strategy as it allows us to leverage funding and learn from others. California is already making great strides, partly though Dr Mitloehner’s research and outreach, and understanding their policies and approaches can inform similar conversations in New Zealand.

 

There has been very little consideration here of policies and measures in other countries, so the visit will fill a gap. 

 

Let's see how other regions are approaching the reduction of agricultural methane and see what we can learn from it.

 

As methane emissions are a significant issue for the sector, it is essential that policy decisions are made with the most up to date science and this public lecture aims to inform and educate policy makers. 

 

Concerns about funding for Dr Mitloehner’s and the CLEAR Centre’s work were raised by Greenpeace last year and then appeared in the New York Times. These were comprehensively addressed by Dr Mitloehner in a response which can be read here. 

 

We believe it is crucial for industry bodies such as B+LNZ, scientists, and policy makers to work together on addressing agricultural greenhouse gas emissions. Dr Mitloehner's visit will make a useful contribution to this co-operative effort.

 

 

Dave Harrison, General Manager Policy, Beef + Lamb New Zealand 


Carbon News stands by its original story but we're happy to provide a right of reply that helps to clarity some of the complicated issues at play.

 

print this story


Related Topics:   Agriculture

More >
New Zealand
More >
Riwaka Sandy Bay Road during recent flooding

'Back-to-basics' approach for councils ignores climate risk

Fri 11 Jul 2025

By Shannon Morris-Williams | While ACT is standing local government candidates to oppose councils' attempts to manage emissions and ministers are calling for local authorities to 'get back to basics' - or even suggesting scrapping regional councils altogether - one expert says this narrative is putting communities at risk in the face of climate change.

Emissions Trading Scheme needs deep reform - commissioner

Fri 11 Jul 2025

The government’s attempt to limit forestry conversions on rural land is unlikely to lead to meaningful change, according to the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment.

‘Significant gaps’ in proposed approach to climate adaptation

Thu 10 Jul 2025

A new report into climate adaptation doesn’t suggest how development in high-risk areas should be avoided - an issue that needs urgent action with thousands of homes still being built in hazardous areas, according to the Environmental Defence Society.

Fast, sustained phase-out of fossil fuels: best-performing countries in coal and transport sectors

Thu 10 Jul 2025

By Robert McLachlan | It’s true that climate change is getting worse – it will continue to get worse until emissions fall to near zero. But is action on phasing out fossil fuels really stalling?

North Canterbury locals get say over huge solar farm

Thu 10 Jul 2025

By David Hill, Local Democracy Reporter | North Canterbury residents are being encouraged to have their say on a proposed 180 hectare solar farm on a property near their village.

Former Climate Commission Chair Dr Rod Carr

Markets aren't going to save us – Carr

Wed 9 Jul 2025

By Shannon Morris-Williams | Consumerism is reaching its ecological and economic limits, and only systemic change - not market tweaks - can steer us away from climate catastrophe, according to former Climate Change Commission chair Rod Carr.

Megan Woods

Climate backtracking could impact trade relationships: Labour

Wed 9 Jul 2025

By Liz Kivi | Labour Party Energy spokesperson Megan Woods says the government needs to be upfront about how its energy policies will impact trade relationships, following revelations New Zealand was warned by other governments that backtracking on climate policies jeopardised its membership of an international alliance.

NZ Post drops science-based climate target

Tue 8 Jul 2025

By Liz Kivi | NZ Post has dropped its science-based emissions reduction target of 42% by 2030 with no plans to replace it.

Mayor Nick Smith and chief executive Nigel Philpott had reservations about the target.

Nelson adopts ambitious target to slash emissions

Tue 8 Jul 2025

By Max Frethey, Local Democracy Reporter | After some of the most passionate debate seen in the chamber this triennium, Nelson City Council has adopted the more ambitious of two community greenhouse gas targets.

Clear-sighted view to trade-offs crucial to reimagining our relationship with the land

Mon 7 Jul 2025

By Nick Swallow | COMMENT: New Zealand could see a 70% drop in the value of dairy land if we pursue our emissions targets for agriculture, according to a new report.

Carbon News

Subscriptions, Advertising & General

[email protected]

Editorial

[email protected]

We welcome comments, news tips and suggestions - please also use this address to submit all media releases for News Direct).

Useful Links
Home About Carbon News Contact us Advertising Subscribe Service Policies
New Zealand
Politics Energy Agriculture Carbon emissions Transport Forestry Business
International
Australia United States China Europe United Kingdom Canada Asia Pacific Antarctic/Arctic Africa South America United Nations
Home
Markets
Analysis NZ carbon price
News Direct
Media releases Climate calendar

© 2008-2025 Carbon News. All Rights Reserved. • Your IP Address: 18.97.14.88 • User account: Sign In

Please wait...
Audit log: