Carbon News
  • Members
    • Login
      Forgot Password?
    • Not a member? Subscribe
    • Forgot Password
      Back to Login
    • Not a member? Subscribe
  • Home
  • New Zealand
    • Politics
    • Energy
    • Agriculture
    • Carbon emissions
    • Transport
    • Forestry
    • Business
  • Markets
    • Analysis
    • NZ carbon price
  • International
    • Australia
    • United States
    • China
    • Europe
    • United Kingdom
    • Canada
    • Asia
    • Pacific
    • Antarctic/Arctic
    • Africa
    • South America
    • United Nations
  • News Direct
    • Media releases
    • Climate calendar
  • About Carbon News
    • Contact us
    • Advertising
    • Subscribe
    • Service
    • Policies

Can oil crisis lead to the economic transformation we desperately need?

Today 11:15am

Depositphotos
Image: Depositphotos

COMMENT: The latest crisis has all the ingredients for the “wake-up call” we need to transform our economy to one fit for the future. But we thought that about COVID as well, writes Catherine Knight.

News over the last week has been whiplash-inducing. The US/Israeli war … oops I mean ‘excursion’… against Iran continues. The Straight of Hormuz through which 20% of the world’s liquid fuels pass remains closed, fuel prices have surged, oil-fuelled inflation is certain to flow through the economy and the much-vaunted economic recovery is very likely off the menu for this year. Meanwhile, in Queensland, Australia, record-breaking floods cause death and carnage, as well as a crocodile incursion, but hardly got a mention.


Alongside rampant fuel-pump anxiety, we had the story of Watties (owned by multinational food company Kraft-Heinz) announcing that it plans to stop producing frozen peas and other frozen vegetables (citing among other things, inability to compete with cheaper imported products), shutting down its factory in Christchurch at the loss of 350 jobs, and affecting hundreds of vegetable growers (at least some of whom are contemplating switching to dairy). This comes after Hawke’s Bay farmers were faced with pulling up their peach trees because home-grown peaches cannot compete with much cheaper imports from China, Greece and South Africa.


And for us as ‘consumers’, why should it matter? As long as we can get our frozen peas and canned peaches from the supermarket at a reasonable price, why should we care where they come from? This is the market doing its job. Whoever can supply a product at the cheapest price wins. This is market fundamentalism at its best – maximising efficiency (for those that control the capital), and externalising all the social, health, environmental and climate costs. Pure efficiency!


But as we enter a world of energy descent,1 intensifying geopolitical conflict over resources (oil, fertiliser, rare-earth metals, water, arable land), trade and supply chain disruption, mass human movement, and of course climate change, it is resilience that we will need to value over the ‘just-in-time’ efficiency of the halcyon days of market fundamentalism. (‘Just in time’ delivery of refined fuel and fertiliser to New Zealand shores – the last bus stop on the Planet - may work while the ships are still coming, less so when their arrival is no longer guaranteed.)


This is a central theme of Nate Hagens’ most recent ‘wide-boundary news’ episode, which I highly recommend.


This latest oil and fertiliser supply scare should provide the ‘Overton Window’ for our politicians to shake off the biospheric blindness, recognise the vulnerabilities of an economy organised around maximising ‘efficiency’ rather than resilience, and putting in place strategies and policies that will support a transition to a resilience-oriented economic system. For instance, if we value food security, the government could implement policies that support local growers and manufacturers of food products, increase product and distributional diversity and reduce the heavy reliance of our agricultural and horticultural systems on imported liquid fuels, fertiliser, agricultural chemicals and machinery.


We have been subsidising an international mining company Rio Tinto to the tune of billions of dollars through cheap electricity (an eighth of all supply) and free carbon credits to produce aluminium on our shores for decades, why not support growers and processors of vegetables, fruit and cereals in New Zealand to continue to produce food at a much lower environmental and climate cost? And while we are at it, how about regulating the sale of highly processed foods that are addictive and linked to obesity, diabetes and cancer, and therefore costs us dearly in terms of demands on the health system, and loss of productivity.


Of course, this would require governance with foresight, something that appears to be in short supply – just like liquid fuels. This is where civil society needs to step in, strengthening our own awareness of the complex, interconnected realities and demanding a response befitting the reality of the escalating polycrisis. Not the faux-solutions (such as the liquified natural gas import terminal) that only further deepen the root cause of our predicament (reliance on imported fossil fuels and overshoot).

                    

This is the purpose of the upcoming Reality of Everything Symposium. Find out more and secure your place here. Can’t make it, but would like to help make politicians aware of the symposium? Please consider sending an email - download the template from the website.



Originally published on An Uncommon Land.


Dr Catherine Knight is an award‑winning author of several books including An Uncommon Land: From an ancestral past of enclosure to a regenerative future. She works in public policy, is an Honorary Research Associate at Massey University, and writes on post-growth and the wellbeing economy.

print this story


Related Topics:   Energy

More >
Energy
More >

Govt finalises geothermal strategy and commits to $50m boost

Thu 19 Mar 2026

By Shannon Morris-Williams | The Government has launched a plan to grow geothermal energy and committed a further $50 million from the Regional Infrastructure Fund to support early-stage projects and drive expansion of the sector.

LNG sold as insurance, but modelling points to a bigger role

Thu 19 Mar 2026

New Zealand’s gas market is heading for a sharp contraction whether the country sticks with domestic supply alone or introduces liquefied natural gas imports.

Oil shock tests Government’s balancing act

Tue 17 Mar 2026

The Government is trying to show it is on top of fuel security risk without giving the impression New Zealand is heading for a shortage.

Mayor stands by comments over AI factory cable

Tue 17 Mar 2026

By Matthew Rosenberg, Local Democracy Reporter | Invercargill mayor Tom Campbell is standing by his view that a new cable for a large AI data factory will not impact the environment at Ōreti Beach, despite a report saying otherwise.

'Power-hungry' AI data centre could push up electricity prices

Mon 16 Mar 2026

By Shannon Morris-Williams | A proposed AI-focused data centre in Southland could become New Zealand’s second-largest electricity user, raising concerns it may drive up power prices and complicate efforts to decarbonise the national grid.

Renewables surge cuts power emissions, but oil dominates fossil fuel use

13 Mar 2026

By Shannon Morris-Williams | New Zealand’s fossil fuel emissions fell in 2025 as strong renewable electricity generation reduced the need for gas-fired power, but oil consumption is rising and now accounts for a record share of fossil emissions.

Todd gets nod to drill first super-critical geothermal well

12 Mar 2026

By Pattrick Smellie | Todd Energy is to make its sole oil drilling rig available to drill the first exploration well under the government’s $60 million super-critical geothermal resource exploration programme under a ‘preferred supplier’ agreement announced yesterday.

(From top left onscreen) Linda Wright, NZ Hydrogen Council CEO, Ian Kennedy, NZ Committee for the Japan-NZ Business Council, Makoto Osawa, Ambassador to NZ, with other NZ Govt and Japanese company reps at the inaugural meeting last week

Japan eyes New Zealand as green hydrogen export hub

12 Mar 2026

By Shannon Morris-Williams | A new partnership between major Japanese companies aims to explore exporting green hydrogen from New Zealand – but the economics of producing the energy-hungry fuel remain the biggest hurdle.

Methanex: a gauge of NZ’s gas decline

12 Mar 2026

Methanex’s latest earnings call offered a blunt reminder that the company’s shrinking New Zealand business is now less a stand-alone corporate story than a barometer of the country’s broader gas decline.

Carbon News

Subscriptions, Advertising & General

[email protected]

Editorial

[email protected]

We welcome comments, news tips and suggestions - please also use this address to submit all media releases for News Direct).

Useful Links
Home About Carbon News Contact us Advertising Subscribe Service Policies
New Zealand
Politics Energy Agriculture Carbon emissions Transport Forestry Business
International
Australia United States China Europe United Kingdom Canada Asia Pacific Antarctic/Arctic Africa South America United Nations
Home
Markets
Analysis NZ carbon price
News Direct
Media releases Climate calendar

© 2008-2026 Carbon News. All Rights Reserved. • Your IP Address: 216.73.216.158 • User account: Sign In

Please wait...
Audit log: