Carbon News
  • Members
    • Login
      Forgot Password?
    • Not a member? Subscribe
    • Forgot Password
      Back to Login
    • Not a member? Subscribe
  • Home
  • New Zealand
    • Politics
    • Energy
    • Agriculture
    • Carbon emissions
    • Transport
    • Forestry
    • Business
  • Markets
    • Analysis
    • NZ carbon price
  • International
    • Australia
    • United States
    • China
    • Europe
    • United Kingdom
    • Canada
    • Asia
    • Pacific
    • Antarctic/Arctic
    • Africa
    • South America
    • United Nations
  • News Direct
    • Media releases
    • Climate calendar
  • About Carbon News
    • Contact us
    • Advertising
    • Subscribe
    • Service
    • Policies

Environmental group challenges forestry claims

13 Sep 2024

A forestry skid site on Ormond Valley Rd pictured in 2019. Eastland Wood Council chairman Julian Kohn says companies are “bleeding money" because of increased costs to build skids, with more earth movement, water control and moving more slash to sustainable areas. Photo / Liam Clayton

 

By Zita Campbell, Local Democracy Reporter

Environmentalists are rejecting claims by a forestry umbrella group that Gisborne District Council does not have the expertise to support and regulate the industry.

Environmentalists are rejecting claims by a forestry umbrella group that Gisborne District Council does not have the expertise to support and regulate the industry.

 

During a presentation to the council last week, Eastland Wood Council chairman Julian Kohn said while forestry made up 32% of the region’s tradeable activity, many forestry companies were finding Gisborne too costly to invest in.

 

Kohn said a balance between social, environmental and economic outcomes needed to be achieved in the forestry space, and highlighted Aratu Forests who, in the last three financial years, had recorded a loss of $218 million.

 

Firms were “bleeding money” because of increased costs to build skids, more earth movement, water control and moving more slash to sustainable areas.

 

The forestry spokesman added that it used to be common forestry practice to spend $100,000 per kilometre on roads but it was now “three times that”.

 

Kohn laid a lot of the cost explosion at the district council’s doorstep, claiming it did not have enough capability, experience and knowledge to balance environmental, economic and social outcomes.

 

However, he also noted forestry was struggling nationwide, especially due to the log market in China.

 

Supporting Kohn’s discussion was East Coast National MP Dana Kirkpatrick, who said that sorting out the changes was crucial, “so we don’t end up in the situation of prosecution and fining people, because that’s not the answer”.

 

“That’s not helpful because it means the same thing is still happening,” she said.

 

In response, environmentalists say the forestry industry needs to look at its own failings.

 

Mana Taiao Tairāwhiti (MTT), a Gisborne group that organised a petition calling for land-use rule changes, said many recent prosecutions of forestry companies had been because they had previously underspent on skid sites, water controls and roads.

 

“There’s a good reason they now need to spend more on doing the job properly.”

 

The group added that many forestry companies in Gisborne had been repeatedly prosecuted but not a lot seemed to change unless enforcement orders were made.

 

MTT said more than a dozen companies in the region had been successfully prosecuted in the past five years.

 

Complaints that harvesting and roading rules were stopping forestry companies from chopping down trees were also dismissed by MTT.

 

The environmentalists said it was central not local government rules that prohibited these discharges through Section 15(1) of the Resource Management Act.

 

The Government announced proposed plans last week to provide a “comprehensive fit-for-purpose National Environment Standard for Commercial Forestry” which would prohibit councils’ ability to make tougher regulations.

 

MTT backed the council’s experience in dealing with the issues of forestry regulations.

 

“Council staff have been telling the central government for more than a decade that they need region-specific tools to regulate activities in the unique geology of Tairāwhiti,” they said.

 

MTT also said the economic figures Kohn used were misleading as while forestry contributed 32% of exports from the region, it accounted for 8.7% of GDP.

 

“And we know the GDP goes up every time a machine is sent to pick up slash from rivers and beaches – hardly something to be proud of.”

 

Infometrics chief executive and principal economist Brad Olsen clarified this disputed figure with Local Democracy Reporting.

 

Olsen said the combined sector of forestry was around 3.4% of the workforce in Tairāwhiti and employed around 10% of the total tradeable sector employment.

 

Technically, clearing slash was a cost to the business and wouldn’t increase the GDP counted for forestry operations. Rather it would detract from the total value of forestry products produced. However, the operator picking up the slash would provide (and be paid for) that service, which would be an increase in GDP for that industry.

 

“Even if the forestry operator was doing that work themselves, the cost of doing that work would limit forestry GDP but likely add to other industries that provide the supplies for the work to be undertaken,” he said.

 

During the council meeting, GDC chief executive Nedine Thatcher Swann noted the presentation was to listen to and not debate. However, “the consents are there for a purpose in terms of the behaviour that we have seen”.

 

Local Democracy Reporting is funded through RNZ and NZ On Air.


Related Topics:   Forestry

More >
Forestry
More >

Farming lobby attacks ‘loopholes’ in carbon forestry limits

7 May 2025

Beef + Lamb New Zealand is urging the government to close what it says are loopholes in new guidance around limits on carbon forestry.

Govt on track to ban farm-to-forest conversions - McClay

2 May 2025

Agriculture and Forestry Minister Todd McClay has confirmed that restrictions on full farm-to-forest conversions on LUC 1-6 farmland will be in place this year.

Commissioner calls for urgent reform of carbon forestry in ETS

10 Apr 2025

The Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment is calling on the Government to remove forestry from the New Zealand Emissions Trading Scheme, warning that the country’s flagship climate policy is entrenching risky land use decisions and undermining long-term emissions reductions.

'Don't tinker with the ETS': forestry groups

10 Apr 2025

Foresters have hit back against the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment’s call to remove forestry from the Emissions Trading Scheme, saying the move would threaten New Zealand’s climate goals.

Slash under the Mangatokerau Bridge on Paroa Road

East Coast advocates join calls to take forestry out of the ETS

10 Apr 2025

Sustainable land-use advocates in Tairāwhiti are demanding immediate government action on the Environment Commissioner's recommendation to phase forestry out of the Emissions Trading Scheme.

Experts back scepticism about carbon forestry

10 Apr 2025

Experts from around the country agree that the Environment Commissioner's 'Alt-F Reset' report is "incredibly timely" as the world faces unprecedented climate change.

Govt plan for forestry on Crown land raises questions for the Emissions Trading Scheme

4 Apr 2025

By Liz Kivi | The government’s latest plan for carbon forestry includes a large chunk of planting on Crown land, with 155,000 hectares of exotic forestry projected to enter the Emissions Trading Scheme by 2042.

Govt releases detail on ETS forestry restrictions

28 Mar 2025

The government has released more detail on new restrictions for farm conversions to exotic forestry in the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS), which foresters say will prevent another planting boom.

Carbon credit deal to provide windfall for Maori landowners

21 Mar 2025

By Moana Ellis, Local Democracy Reporting | An isolated Maori Land Trust in the central North Island has sealed a groundbreaking carbon credit deal, securing millions for its 4000 owners and tens of thousands of beneficiaries.

Govt calls for tenders to improve remote sensing for carbon storage

18 Mar 2025

The government has issued a request for proposals to help it improve how carbon stored in forests can be measured by remote-sensing.

Carbon News

Subscriptions, Advertising & General

manager@carbonnews.co.nz

Editorial

news@carbonnews.co.nz

We welcome comments, news tips and suggestions - please also use this address to submit all media releases for News Direct).

Useful Links
Home About Carbon News Contact us Advertising Subscribe Service Policies
New Zealand
Politics Energy Agriculture Carbon emissions Transport Forestry Business
International
Australia United States China Europe United Kingdom Canada Asia Pacific Antarctic/Arctic Africa South America United Nations
Home
Markets
Analysis NZ carbon price
News Direct
Media releases Climate calendar

© 2008-2025 Carbon News. All Rights Reserved. • Your IP Address: 18.97.14.83 • User account: Sign In

Please wait...
Audit log: